I was a Costco shopper back in college and the early days of our marriage. Then one year I opted not to renew my membership, primarily because the location of the nearest Costco was totally out of the way. Since then I've been a Winco shopper. If you want the lowest prices, without having to check ads or clip coupons, then that is the store for you. They also have a gigantic bulk department, which I love, love, love.
Several years ago I started clipping coupons from the Sunday paper and using some sites that helped me find the best deals at a few drug and grocery stores. I still did 95% of my shopping at Winco, but I hit a couple stores every Sunday morning for a few smokin' deals. I didn't pay for shampoo, conditioner, razors, toothbrushes, toothpaste, dental floss, over the counter meds, or various other things for years. In fact, many times I earned money by taking them out of the store. I did pay for other items, but they were dirt cheap. I never spent more than a quarter for a bag of pasta, fifty cents for mustard, or four bucks for a block of Tillamook. I'm a generic kind of shopper, but everything we were getting for free or cheap was name brand. We had four to five people in our family and my grocery budget was $300 a month. That included all food, toiletries, paper products, and diapers. (Let me discreetly add that, thanks to the downsides of heredity, one of those categories required a much bigger budget than most people would think. Do you read me?) It was wonderful!
Then grocery prices started climbing. We kept our budget the same, but cut out some non-essentials. They kept climbing. We made some more cuts. We were still eating well, though, and it was fine.
Eventually it became hard to stay in the budget, so I bumped us to $350 right around the time we moved last year. The extra wiggle room was nice, but now we live 20 miles from the closest Winco and it's a hassle to go there. Shopping locally, however, is too expensive. As for my couponing, I haven't clipped a coupon in a very, very long time. The days of that being worthwhile are long gone for me. The deals now are unimpressive and require printing out various internet coupons, so I'd just quit doing it. It wasn't cost effective.
So we decided to try Costco again last spring. We figured I could still hit Winco occasionally, once a month or less, but we thought it may work to make Costco be our primary store. There's a Costco near church, which makes shopping there really convenient. We knew some of their prices were lower, others higher, and many comparable to Winco and we figured the money saved from cancelling our paper subscription and the time and gas money saved by not travelling to Winco may balance out the things that were more expensive. Additionally, we knew they had low gas prices and we thought that would be icing on the cake.
We gave ourselves some extra in the budget for the first couple months, as we knew it would take a while to adjust to buying the large packages of things there, but planned to be back to our regular budget within three months. Then I lost my milk supply when Teebs was five months old. There was no way we could take $70 of Kirkland formula from our $350 monthly budget for seven months. So I bumped us to $400.
But Costco just isn't working out for us. I'll explain why, but first let me say that I like Costco. The employees are friendly, the shelves are always stocked, they have great prices on a lot of food and non-food items, I love being able to grab several cans of olives (or whatever) at once, and it's handy to not have to fill multiple bulk bags.
The problem is that there are so many things we buy that Costco doesn't carry, which means I still have to go to Winco on a regular basis. Other things are a great deal at Costco if you're brand loyal, but still way more expensive than a generic brand at Winco. And other things I simply don't need in Costco quantities. So, I'm actually making more shopping trips now than I was before. That just doesn't work for me, at least not in this season of life. We also started running out of grocery money before the end of the month when we were shopping at Costco, which had never happened before.
Ironically, the thing most people say is better at Costco than Winco is produce, but I actually had Costco produce go bad more quickly than Winco's. Go figure.
One totally superficial complaint? I hate their milk jugs. A lot. I've never had more milk spilled in our home than when we started buying those jugs.
Vent over.
So, what now?
Well, the first time I paid $3 a blade for a package of razors at Costco I realized that my disappointment in the fact that I can't get them free (or make money off them) at the drugstores and my unwillingness (until now) to pay $1 for them there was something I was going to have to get over. Yikes! I'm not convinced that Sunday coupons would be worth the cost of a subscription at this point, but I am going to start watching the drugstore ads again for non-food items. I just need to go back with the realization that the glory days of drugstore shopping are over and shift my target prices accordingly.
Our Costco membership still has several months left on it, so I'm sure we'll still pop in for some things and we'll keep getting gas there, but I don't think we'll be renewing our membership. I'm glad we gave it another try, though. Now we know. In another season of life we may feel differently and start shopping there more regularly again, but Winco works for us now. If only they'd open one closer to us!
Incidentally, we recently qualified for food stamps and our grocery budget increased significantly. We were given our benefits after this month had started, but our caseworker recently called Tim to let him know what we'd be getting next month. Ummmm .... $900. What in the world?! Yes, I know it's a screwy system when an employed family can easily feed itself on a fraction of what the state will allot them when they're unemployed. Yes, I'm also thankful that we know how we're going to feed our family each month until Tim has full-time employment again.
But $900? Just for food? When we're currently spending $400 for food, formula, diapers, toiletries, and paper products? Yes, I realize we could go all organic, but I can't justify that. Personal conviction and no judgement toward those who use food stamps that way. I'm really not sure, though, how else we could possibly spend that much money, unless we ate steak every night. Goodness gracious! So, what will we do with all the excess money? I don't know. We may buy some extra non-perishables. We'll probably let most of the extra sit and let the state keep it. I'll definitely allow myself a little more wiggle room in our budget, which will be nice for my brain when it's time to plan a menu, but I'm not going to go nuts just because I can.
And that's the latest update on our shopping habits. Exciting, isn't it?
10 comments:
I don't know if its ethical or not but there are so many families not on food stamps trying to stay in a small budget, could you buy extra and give it to them? $900??!! That is a lot!!!! Stock up on everything you can!!!
For goodness sakes, don't let it sit!! Stock up on non perishables. Once you're stocked, and your freezer is full, bless other people.
On the paper thing, I just pick up a Sunday paper. It's not really worth it to me to buy a subscription. I clip coupons for stuff that I know we'll use. Razors drive me crazy--I'm buying razors for 5 people!!! I literally write their names on them, and don't buy new ones, but once a month. Or people will just use and toss.
Our food budget is currently $675 for 6 of us, and I am having a hard time hitting that.
I like Sams much better than Costco--mostly for meat. Early Mondays, I can get beef for half off.
Winco is my very favorite, and I think of you every time I'm there. Hang in there! Praying for you, and asking God how I can bless you during this hard time, but haven't 'heard' yet.
Kore - I'm assuming it's frowned upon to use state money to buy food for people who don't qualify for the state money themselves ... which totally makes sense.
Maryanne - It's crazy, huh? You're right that you can't win for losing with food stamps. I've read the comments online and seen the looks in real life.
Kore - I probably will do some stocking up, but I don't want to spend it just to spend it. Plus, I'd have to store it all somewhere. :) Writing names on the razors is brilliant!
Bethany - Use the extra $ to stock up. Buy canned and dried good that have an expiration date of 2014. If you can buy paper products, stock up on paper towels and toilet paper. Think of other non-perishables that you will use over the next 2 years... and stock up.
I'd stock up on non perishables.
There's a Walmart Market Place that just opened on Jean Way in LO. I went there last night. They pretty much only have food, but you may check it out. No bins though. But the employees were really helpful, the place was super clean and really nice. ; )
Hmmmm....sounds like maybe the Lord is giving you "7 years of plenty". Please hear me that in now way am I implying that you will go through "7 years of famine" but it looks like He is providing for you to stock up on non-perishables. :)
Do you not like Walmart? We definitely like Winco better than Walmart but aren't you guys in the same town as Walmart now? At the beginning of your post, you said it's too expensive to shop locally... with $900 a month now, you should shop locally!!
I've never shopped at Winco or WalMart because they are too far from me, but I was wondering how WalMart's prices compare to Winco.
Also, Our libraries get extra Sunday newspapers first thing Saturday morning and give them away. It might be a way for you to get coupons if you want to go back to that sort of thing.
Cheri - Ok. I'll get some extra non-perishables. :)
Maryanne - Good point! We don't eat junky, but we don't eat organically either. We also don't have any medical problems and are very rarely sick.
Deana - I've been convinced. :)
Rachel - I'm one mile from a regular WM. :)
Mary Lou - All the comments here and on FB have me feeling more comfortable with buying extras of some non-perishables. I just have a hard time using the excess money to eat better than we do when we are supporting ourselves, but we eat a lot of non-perishables that I could stock up on.
Meghan - No, I don't like it. We shopped there a handful of times when we first moved here, simply for convenience, but it wasn't any bargain, the lines are always crazy long, they were often out of produce we needed, and we buy a lot from bulk bins, which they don't have. We still pop in there on occasion for random things, but I don't want to make it my main store.
Melanie - Winco beats Walmart on prices. Thanks for the heads up on the library. I'll have to ask about that next time I'm in there.
I may start doing a bi-monthly trip to Winco for stocking up non-perishables and getting some perishables, then supplementing with whatever great deals Safeway (local), Albertsons, Freddy's, and Thriftway (near church) have the rest of the month. I don't know.
Post a Comment