The big boys and I always have an ongoing conversation about school choices - the things we like, things we don't like, and what our ideal school situation would be. Our kids don't have the final say, but their opinions are big factors in our decisions, especially as they get older. Both Silas and Devon are content right now, but one has recently said that if the decision was totally up to them and if they had to decide right now what to do next year, then they'd come home. They do, however, want to stay put for the remainder of this year. The other says one day that they would stay where they are, then says on another day that they would come home. Both boys have conditions about coming home.
Incidentally, I have spent the last couple weeks really wanting to bring them home, something I hadn't told them when they shared their thoughts about next year. However, as much as I want to bring them home, I know that there would have to be some big changes in the way we do things if that were to happen next year. In other words, the boys aren't the only ones with conditions about coming home.
I love the idea of homeschooling and I love many of the ways it played out for us, but the overall reality of it was not working for our family anymore. Last year was horrid on multiple levels for our family, some of which were rooted in homeschooling, and I'm not willing to intentionally subject us to that life again. Of course, there were other things contributing to the struggles of last year that had absolutely nothing to do with education at all, some of which are better, others that will be better by next school year, and some that we have little control over. So I only want to bring them the big boys home if we can do it in a way that works for all of us as individuals and for our family as a whole. I want to bring them home for successful homeschooling, not for constant failure, tension, and discouragement. So we'll see what happens.
I've written down the things that I would need for homeschooling to work for me again and I'm going to have the big boys do the same thing. I'm going to start figuring out now if it's possible to accomplish the things on my list for next year, then we'll look at the boys' lists and I'll get some input from Naomi. It may be that we all realize keeping Silas and Devon out is still the best option, or that bringing one home and keeping the other out would work well, or that we all want everyone to come back home and just homeschool differently than before. I have no idea. I just know that we can never go back to the old way of doing things. It worked for a long time, but seasons change. We're at a point where we can't simply choose homeschool or public school. Instead we have to choose between "homeschooling according to this flexible plan that we all invested time and energy into figuring out and believe will be our best option for successful education and a happy home" and public school.
One year ago I knew with total confidence that I would not homeschool everyone this year and I had complete peace about that decision. This year is different. I'm not sure what next year will look like. As always, I believe every schooling choice has inherent pros and cons. I also believe some pros and cons are subjective, depending greatly on the kid, family, school, and season of life. Regardless of how things play out and what schooling choices we make for next year, I continue to be thankful that we live in a time and place with so many options available to us.
So, we'll keep taking it one year and one kid at a time, pray for wisdom, do our research, and then make the decision we believe is best.
Meanwhile, I'm looking forward to the fact Thanksgiving and conferences mean that all my kids will be home next week!
7 comments:
You are a wise women to keep weighting the decision and putting it before Christ. I am confident that whatever choice is made you will continue to see the blessings in that choice.
I have to say that when I started Sonlight, and moments still this year, I felt like a failure. I think it's too voluminous of a curriculum, especially with a family of 4 kids. So, what's worked better for us is scaling way back on the curriculum. We do Total Language Plus for LA, and I have him do it at a slower pace. I've changed bible readings to a devotion book for kids because he wasn't enjoying how dry and long the bible time was - which is not what I want him to feel about devotion time. I also keep his school day to only 2-3 or so hours - anything beyond that and he's fried and so am I. I pick up missing subjects at other times when he has energy and is bored. That's just what has worked for us for this year.
Kristal - Thanks. :)
Kami - Nothing to make a box-checker chill out better than homeschooling. At least that's been my experience. :) I'm glad you've found a groove that's working for you guys! School stuff is constantly shifting. I think it has to if you want it to continue.
Yes - shifting is very good! I love to hear another homeschooling mom's struggles because I feel like it's comes easy to so many (I could be very wrong), and I have so many struggles with it. It's nice to know I'm not the only one :). Keep us posted! BTW - do you feel like Songlight kept the boys on par, above average or below average with public school? I'm always curious about that.
Kami - I never have and never will share test scores with anyone other than the child who tested, but I will say that I have been satisfied with their achievement testing scores and their transition to public school has been smooth academically. In our experience, SL did not leave us lacking academically for the kids who have moved to public school (we went through core 5). How's that for a vague non-answer? :)
Oh, thanks. I wouldn't ask for test scores :). Glad to hear SL did it's job well!
Kami - I'm re-reading my last comment and it sounds way snarkier on the screen than it did in my head. Sorry! :) I didn't think you were asking for scores, but I know that's one way people figure out if their approach to homeschooling is working academically and a lot of parents do share their kids scores ... hence my comment about not sharing. :)
Post a Comment